[oclug] Some thoughts on law and open source volunteers

Peter Timusk ptimusk at sympatico.ca
Thu Jun 10 10:34:41 EDT 2004


>

Thanks for your thoughts. I knew it was weak. It scored B+ last year. I 
was in a way not trying to discover the answer but argue my answer. 
This is a problem with law and courts they don't look for the absolute 
truth rather the best argued truth. I find writing one of my weaker 
skills but I am working on it.


> While I don't necessarily disagree with your conclusions, you just 
> don't
> make a convincing argument. You've examined just a few examples that
> aren't really related to your thesis that "volunteers run the internet"
> and then simply jump to the conclusion.
>
> The thesis is intriquing and it is certainly worth examining
> in more detail, but you need to examine the subject much more closely
> than you have. A few relevant examples would help, as well as examining
> the counter argument. In fact, you may just discover that the internet
> is not run by volunteers at all, but by corporatists and communists for
> example.
>
>>>> --fja->
>
Peter Timusk, B.Math, just trying to stay linear.




More information about the OCLUG mailing list